Tools

pe3 said

pe3  

Panel Discussion: Envisioning Openness – Concrete Proposals

80 comments

pe3 posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

80 comments

Bottom

pe3  

test

pe3 commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

tuffnellpark  

another test

tuffnellpark commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

totoroki  

We hear you :) Through the stream as well.

totoroki commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

totoroki  

So no perkeles there :)

totoroki commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

troppone  

@hyvaelama "Chief Turbulence Officer" ;)

troppone commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

teroheiskanen  

yes, there is @hyvaelama

teroheiskanen commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

khk  

and Massimo from the morning

khk commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

khk  

khk commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

troppone  

I got somehow intrigued by combining openness in physical and virtual worlds even more and better (ok, I'm OT already...)

troppone commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

khk  

a collective document at http://bit.ly/open-proposals

khk commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

juhak  

Panelists:
Ossi Kuittinen (Sitra)
Massimo Menichinelli (Open Peer-to-Peer Design)
Esko Reinikainen (Monmouthshire County Council, Wales UK)

juhak commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

khk  

e-car process - we could go further - rebuilding society

khk commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

khk  

redesign the health care system

khk commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

troppone  

@hyvaelama: how about an eCar-like approach to dismantling openly e.g. healthcare and rebuild to be more people-centric and humane

troppone commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

khk  

Massimo: have more local places for social innovation

khk commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

troppone  

there's a brand for the Suomi-brand workgroup: "open-source Finland"
(sidenote: Torvalds is not in the group, is he...?)

troppone commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

juhak  

Massimo: 100 000 garages

juhak commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

pni  

pni commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

andreuchis  

Hans: put your tweet in here!

andreuchis commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

hanspoldoja  

#open2009 in 140 chars: create movements, not tools; open should be the default, closed should be an option; wikiplanning; 5* for organizers

hanspoldoja commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

andreuchis  

what is missing asks petri: women!

andreuchis commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

troppone  

@hanspoldoja nicely put! Ditto that!

troppone commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

troppone  

@pe3 was asking about women in eCars project - but now apparently excitement among the crowd :)

troppone commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

troppone  

troppone commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

juhak  

juhak commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

bobotus  

bobotus commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

troppone  

@reinikainen "Large group interventions" mentioned, and analogy to deliberative democracy

troppone commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

troppone  

hmm, if our democracy does not engage well enough, should we look to other forms...didn't expect that thought from the panel (although that was not necessarily an opinion)

troppone commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

mace  

With my point to copyleft and FabLab was that there should be a penalty on closedness, f.ex. a property tax on immaterial rights. I'm trying to draft tools to answer @hyvaelama's wish for capturing value.

mace commented on posted to #OPEN2009 Helsinki 06.11.2009 (en)

khk  

Petri asks the panel, what could we do with healthcare. I ask what is the problem with health care?

khk commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

SebastianFiedler  

hi there... could someone be so kind and name (or introduce) the panel participants?
(just joined the video stream...)

SebastianFiedler commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

andreuchis  

@SebastianFiedler
Panelists:
Ossi Kuittinen (Sitra)
Massimo Menichinelli (Open Peer-to-Peer Design)
Esko Reinikainen (Monmouthshire County Council, Wales UK)

andreuchis commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

juhak  

@sebastianfiedler They were announced earlier in the thread. Here they are:

Ossi Kuittinen (Sitra)
Massimo Menichinelli (Open Peer-to-Peer Design)
Esko Reinikainen (Monmouthshire County Council, Wales UK)

juhak commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

SebastianFiedler  

thanks very much... had a look at the program but couldn't find any names there...

SebastianFiedler commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

juhak  

We're living in a world full of information silos

juhak commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

troppone  

@hyvaelama wants me-centric not system-centric approach

troppone commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

viilee  

one fundamental paradigm shift in health care will be the shift to more preventive healthcare (as opposed to treating conditions after they have emerged). this is a huge shift which has a lot to do with "lifestyle" issues. it will be backed up with the increasing understanding of the how the human body works, for example in the field of genetics and, for example, how genes are represented in the individual.

viilee commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

juhak  

The thread Ossi mentioned (maybe)

juhak commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

andreuchis  

@viilee I agree, at least in Finland the preventive healthcare actions are almost inexistant (IMHO)

andreuchis commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

viilee  

@juhak ei taida olla toi.

viilee commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

mace  

There's a very interesting discussion about health information around cancer screening, btw. Check it out!

mace commented on posted to #OPEN2009 Helsinki 06.11.2009 (en)

viilee  

@andreuchis yes. pohjois-karjala-projekti is one big public health project: http://fi.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pohjois-...

viilee commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

juhak  

@viilee heitä hakusana

juhak commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

teroheiskanen  

human's health is his/her own, system has to support that human empowers him/herself through controlling and flourishing his/her health

teroheiskanen commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

viilee  

viilee commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

khk  

one clear area of codesign and living lab development would be in developing the service interface - e.g. the Active Seniors and similar communities would ave a lot of expert knowledge and ideas as "customers", if some institutions would want to find out.

khk commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

troppone  

Patients Like Me -project mentioned

troppone commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

ikajaste  

P2P healthcare system? A platform for excanging information about health conditions. Website: "Patients like me"

ikajaste commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

andreuchis  

@viilee yes what? they are nonexistent or they exist? maybe they exist but they have NEVER touch my experience (last time yesterday with my 5 year old daughtr in the dermatologist)

andreuchis commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

mace  

@andreuchis wait, no preventive healthcare in Finland? I see plenty of it, but of course it doesn't happen in hospitals (hospitals are for sick ppl). It happens in schools, kindergardens, between ppl themselves, football fields, television, magazines and so forth.

mace commented on posted to #OPEN2009 Helsinki 06.11.2009 (en)

viilee  

@andreuchis well, i don't know. though i was told by a doctor friend that the situation is not that bad.

viilee commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

khk  

But @hyvaelama is right, everyone would benefit from at least having the same information available to oneself as the health care institutions have of us.

khk commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

mace  

The ultimate, preventive p2p healthcare is lenkkikaveri!

mace commented on posted to #OPEN2009 Helsinki 06.11.2009 (en)

khk  

(unless it falls into the wrong hands because I was not careful...)

khk commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

troppone  

@mace what's the ultimate preventive p2p mental healthcare? friendship? ;)

troppone commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

khk  

@mace - agree :)

khk commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

andreuchis  

@mace @viilee I stand on my opinion in the "health care system" in this country does not include enough prevention actions

andreuchis commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

hyvaelama  

hyvaelama commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

troppone  

@khk in an ironic way I think the fact that our private date is weirdly stuck in various closed systems prevents the "health data theft" => do people want to change this!?

troppone commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

viilee  

@andreuchis that is true. check out the work of dean ornish on this topic: http://www.pmri.org/lifestyle_program...

viilee commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

khk  

@troppone - exactly, that is one of the main objections for even communicating it.

khk commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

andreuchis  

sanna: secure channel for my info and a channel for people also to contribute back

andreuchis commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

khk  

Health centers do not send email, because of privacy concerns.

khk commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

khk  

Poll was closed!!! already?

khk commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

bobotus  

Information only in finnish, But there is eKatselu, eResepti, and other e-projects on helthcare on the way: http://www.stm.fi/vireilla/kehittamis...

bobotus commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

troppone  

an open-source model still emphasizes the loud minority...

troppone commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

mace  

This discussion is not about the healthcaresystem, it's about personal health information and processing, managing and owning it. This is not about how to decide if we should have only a few, big hospitals or many small ones.

mace commented on posted to #OPEN2009 Helsinki 06.11.2009 (en)

troppone  

oh no...somehow I don't trust TEKES, I really hope I'm wrong!

troppone commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

juhak  

@khk We gave it some extra time. Sanna announced originally that it would close at 16:30

juhak commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

khk  

@juhak ok...my bad, not listen :(

khk commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

troppone  

@hyvaelama suggests bottom-up movement in Mikkeli, where there a will to do social media (& related phenomena) -based actions is in the strategy

troppone commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

troppone  

Great, @reinikainen mentioned the threat to politicians, not unlike what has been suggested by e.g. Axel Bruns

troppone commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

khk  

one central issue in the OS approach, whether eCar or health systems, there need to be the people who code, do CAD, have expertise in the necessary areas....they need to become excited about the changes and design/implement them - the interest and need of the other stakeholders is not enough :(

khk commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

juhak  

To people present and away (symposium spam):

We are having a party at taik from 18-21 here at TaiK Sampo upper foyer. Music, free wine and interesting discussions. There we also announce the biggest polling paper and video. All openers welcome!

juhak commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

viilee  

administration has the power to solve the big problems but often focuses on the small problems whereas designers nowadays want to work on the big problems but really have only the power to work on the small ones.

solution: designers should start wanting to become administrators and managers (and i'm completely serious with this! look, no smiley!!).

there are many inspiring stories regarding this. one is the story of jaime lerner, a brazilian architect who became the mayor of curitiba and had a very unique way of running the city through which they developed an unique local transport system which is cheap and works very well.

here's a link to jaime lerner's presentation at TED: http://www.ted.com/talks/jaime_lerner...

viilee commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

hongisto  

@khk yes it is a very suble way to collaborate, we in fact depend on the ability of co-design (if it can be called so) in the way you are commenting about

hongisto commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

tarmo  

Talking about Mikkeli: Minun Mikkelini

tarmo commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

totoroki  

Thank you for the awesome symposium and have a nice cocktail session over there!

totoroki commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

visualradio  

Arrived back from shop to see the last minutes of panel discussion. I think the limits and possibilities of openness are becoming more clear. The big issue is how to get the huge silent majority to become a part of this? Will it lead to the escape of the pioneers into some kind of new gray zones? How much empathy is open source loaded with? Is there a real and deep concern for a better society and wellbeing of people?

visualradio commented on posted to #OPEN2009 06.11.2009 (en)

Login or register to leave a comment

Publicity
These messages are public and can be seen by anyone.